Monday, March 2, 2009

Great Expectations #3

After many years of a sort of blind ignorance for pip and Estella, they both stumble upon some very upsetting truths. During the beginning of the novel, Pip has held a crush for Estella but after seeing her again recently after several years, he falls into a deep emotional attachment that borders on obsession. He begins to show the signs of a garden variety romantic and believes that Miss Havisham is the only possible benefactor for Pip, as part of a preexisting plan to pair Estella and him for marriage. But in chapter 38, Pip comes to the shocking conclusion that Estella is also leading on a one Bentley Drummle, a young man that Pip finds less than flattering. Estella had been warning Pip for a long time that she would never love him, and he never took heed until he believed she betrayed him. While Pip is obviously devastated by this sudden upset, it is not quite clear of what Pip will go about doing. There are many possibilities for Pip: he could stay with the convict, his actual benefactor, go with Herbert Pocket, among the other possibilities for a young wealthy gentleman. But it is evident that as with most romantics, such as Romeo in the end of the famous Romeo and Juliet, after making the pursuit of Estella the center of his existence, he will have an immensely hard time coping with the "loss" of his love. On of the most prominent reasons for Pip wanting to distinguish himself as a gentlemen and develop his potential was to be able to woo Estella, but since that possibility is extinct, he most likely will not commit suicide as Romeo did, but Pip may find himself without a purpose in his life. Estella has spent her entire life being groomed by her adoptive mother, Miss Havisham, for her personal revenge plot against the male gender. But after all those years in chapter 38, Estella begins to find her mother's constant attention to her very annoying and finally realizes that her mother is demanding too much from her. After a long and violent debate between the two, they soon seem to have re-sewn the holes but an unsettling sense has fallen between them. "Nor, did Miss Havisham's manner towards estella in anywise change, except that I believed it to have something like fear infused among it's former characteristics" (308). I believe that after this sudden spurt of individuality by Estella, Miss Havisham will try to make her squeeze even tighter. How Estella will respond is up in the air; however, she has already proved that she can speak and defend for herself.

2 comments:

  1. lyke O 。M 。G SAM SHALOM I lyke TOTALLY AGREE!
    ^lol oh god^

    yea, but seriously I thought I was the only one who thought Estella was starting to rebel against Miss Havisham. This could be because like you said, "Estella begins to find her mother's constant attention to her very annoying and finally realizes that her mother is demanding too much from her." Demanding too much from her,shows Estella that she's had enough and Miss Havisham can't control her life forever. Like on page 305 Miss Havisham exclaims to Estella, "Estella, Estella, Estella, to be proud to and hard to me!" This shows us how Estella is now going against Havisham because she is rebelling and possibly, like you said, finds Havisham to be "annoying" and ultimately demanding too much or expecting too much.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree on your feelings about Estella's/Miss Havisham's relationship, and how it will evolve in the future, but I also think in the future she will continue to get more and more angry with Miss Havisham. I agree with your points about Estella starting to show rebellion towards and disobeying her adoptive mother. Estella seems to no longer want to just go along with everything that Miss Havisham wants her to do (tease boys, torture people, etc), and is also angry because she is realizing that Miss Havisham "ruined" her. Because of Miss Havisham, she is unable to feel love, and finds joy in other peoples pain. On page 267, Estella talks about how hard it was to grow up in Miss Havisham's house. This shows that the hard conditions of her up bringing led to how she is today, and how in the future she is likely to rebel more and act in response to those prior conditions.

    ReplyDelete